As the US edges as much as the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence in 2026, one of many core ideas the founders sought to advance – that the federal government should act with accountability and in accordance with the rule of legislation – is being strongly examined.
Of their deliberations main as much as the declaration, the founders wouldn’t simply increase deep considerations that the federal government of King George III was violating the Colonists’ rights, which they described within the declaration. They’d additionally enshrine these ideas within the U.S. Structure over a decade later by the idea of “due process.”
What did the framers seemingly imply once they did so? That’s not merely an educational query for authorized students like me. The that means and utility of due course of has grow to be an important concern within the U.S., most frequently with respect to the Trump administration’s migrant deportation efforts.
Over the previous a number of months, the U.S. Supreme Court docket has made a number of rulings in deportation-related circumstances with respect to what’s referred to as the due course of clause of the Structure.
In April 2025, within the case Trump v. J.G.G., the courtroom appeared to state fairly clearly that deportations couldn’t happen with out due course of. Extra just lately, nevertheless, in D.H.S. v. D.V.D., the Supreme Court docket prevented a decrease courtroom from offering due course of protections to a gaggle of males the administration wished to deport to South Sudan, the place they’re susceptible to going through torture and even demise.
These seemingly contradictory rulings not solely make it unclear when due course of applies however in all probability depart many asking what the time period “due process of law” even means and the way it works.
Over the previous a number of months, the U.S. Supreme Court docket has made a number of rulings about due course of in deportation-related circumstances.
Mike Kline, Second/Getty Pictures
The origins of due course of
The American idea of due course of might be traced from medieval England to its fashionable formulation by the U.S. Supreme Court docket. Doing so permits the that means of due course of to return into focus. It additionally calls into query the courtroom’s most up-to-date ruling on this concern.
The ideas of due course of and the rule of legislation largely emerged within the thirteenth century within the Magna Carta, a proper, written settlement between King John of England and the insurgent aristocracy that successfully established authorized constraints on authorities.
One key passage from the Magna Carta offered that “No Freeman shall be taken, or any otherwise imprisoned, or be disseised of his Freehold, or Liberties, or free Customs, or be outlawed, or exiled, or destroyed; nor we will not pass upon him, nor condemn him, but by lawful Judgment of his Peers, or by the Law of the Land.”
This accord established formal constraints on a beforehand unrestrained regent, setting English legislation on the course that may prioritize rule of legislation over the whims of the monarch.
Over a century later, Parliament would go the English statute of 1354 that stated “That no Man of what Estate or Condition that he be, shall he put out of Land or Tenement, nor taken nor imprisoned, nor disinherited, nor put to death, without being brought in Answer by due Process of the Law.”
These principlesd evolve over time in British legislation after which knowledgeable the rising revolutionary spirit within the American Colonies.
Launched in January 1776, Thomas Paine’s pamphlet Frequent Sense would assist impress and metal many Colonists for the revolutionary battle to return. The work shifted the main focus of Colonists’ anger from attempting to power the king to deal with them higher to extra radical change: independence and a rustic ruled by the rule of legislation.
Thomas Paine wrote on this influential 1776 political pamphlet, ‘For as in absolute governments the King is law, so in free countries the law ought to be King; and there ought to be no other.’
Library of Congress Uncommon E book and Particular Collections Division
What the Colonists wished, Paine wrote, was not a monarch: “So far as we approve of monarchy, that in America THE LAW IS KING. For as in absolute governments the King is law, so in free countries the law ought to be King; and there ought to be no other.”
Defining due course of
After independence, lots of the unique 13 states adopted their very own constitutions that may enshrine ideas akin to due course of to guard their constituents from authorities overreach, similar to that authorities was to be certain, because it was in Virginia’s Declaration of Rights in 1776, by “the law of the land.”
However it was not till the nation adopted the Invoice of Rights – the primary 10 amendments to the Structure – in 1791 that the federal authorities couldn’t act in a method that disadvantaged the populace of life, liberty or property with out due technique of legislation. After the Civil Battle, the 14th Modification would apply these identical protections to all authorities motion, state and federal.
The modern and most complete formulation of what due course of requires might be discovered within the Supreme Court docket’s ruling within the 1970 case Goldberg v. Kelly, introduced by welfare recipients difficult their lack of such advantages with no listening to.
In that case, the courtroom decided that when governments try and deprive somebody of their life, liberty or property, the goal of these makes an attempt should obtain honest discover of the costs or claims in opposition to them that may justify that loss; be given a possibility to defend in opposition to these claims; and possess the precise to have such defenses thought of by an neutral adjudicator.
The Supreme Court docket in 1976 would settle for that due course of protections in several settings will differ primarily based on plenty of variables. These embrace what’s at stake within the case, the probability that authorities would possibly make a mistake in a specific setting, and the advantages and burdens of offering sure types of course of in a given scenario.
When somebody’s life is actually on the road, for instance, extra exacting procedures are required. On the identical time, no matter how vital the curiosity that’s topic to due course of – whether or not it’s one’s life, one’s dwelling, one’s liberty, or one thing else – the elements of honest discover, a possibility to be heard, and to have one’s case determined by an neutral adjudicator should be significant.
Because the courtroom stated in Mullane vs. Central Hanover Financial institution & Belief Co. in 1950: “Process which is a mere gesture is not due process.”
