Ebook Overview
The Truth Checker
By Austin KelleyAtlantic Month-to-month Press: 256 pages, $27If you purchase books linked on our web site, The Instances might earn a fee from Bookshop.org, whose charges assist impartial bookstores.
The duvet of Austin Kelley’s debut novel, “The Fact Checker,” will likely be instantly recognizable to a sure kind of individual: Ah, the New Yorker, they could suppose, earlier than blinking and realizing that it isn’t.
I’m that type of individual; the well-known weekly has been round my entire life, points piled on the toilet counter or mendacity open on the kitchen desk, and I ultimately learn them as properly. Sooner or later, I realized about its well-known fact-checkers, the individuals who toil away in relative obscurity (the journal doesn’t record them anyplace, although you could discover some by trawling LinkedIn) in an effort to ensure that each factual assertion the journal publishes is appropriate — even when these info seem inside poetry.
“The Fact Checker” is narrated by a person holding the titular title who’s, primarily, a flâneur: a literary kind who wanders round his city setting, observing and commenting on society from a considerably indifferent place. Whereas the journal he works for stays unnamed, it’s clearly meant to be the New Yorker; however readers hoping for juicy insider gossip will likely be disenchanted (precise insiders — those that have been round within the mid-aughts, anyway — might acknowledge the kinds and tempers Kelley’s narrator interacts with at work). The title, the quilt, the font — they’re all somewhat efficient bait.
Truth-checking does characteristic within the novel, after all. The primary plot, which takes place in July and August 2004, kicks off when the narrator is given an article to verify concerning the Union Sq. Greenmarket — known as Mandeville/Inexperienced for its writer and topic, respectively. It’s a easy sufficient piece, and the fact-checker offers with a lot of it briefly order. However one quote, about “nefarious business” happening on the market, makes him pause, and he goes searching for the supply, Sylvia, in an effort to verify what she advised the writer and ask for particulars.
Sylvia is a basic Manic Pixie Dream Woman: Mandeville says she’s “interesting,” which the narrator acknowledges is likely to be a euphemism for her being insane and/or attractive. She has a particular characteristic (a scar) that appears to intensify her magnificence to the narrator’s eyes, and is enthusiastic about issues, together with the tomatoes she grows. She takes the narrator on a journey, first to a cemetery after which to a secret supper membership run out of a squatted-in workplace within the Monetary District of Decrease Manhattan; she grew up on a commune and claims it was a cult, actually, however she likes the thought of cults: “If you are in a cult, you are really committed, worshiping the Deity. Worshiping the good. That’s all I want to do in this life. Worship the good.”
After sleeping with the narrator, she leaves him a observe promising to name and promptly disappears. He spends the remainder of the novel making an attempt to trace her down. Very like critic Nathan Rabin’s definition of the Manic Pixie Dream Woman kind who exists “in the fevered imaginations of sensitive writer-directors,” Sylvia is there “to teach broodingly soulful young men to embrace life and its infinite mysteries and adventures.”
The Truth Checker, who isn’t totally over an ex-girlfriend who cheated on him together with her dissertation advisor — one other acquainted kind — is one such younger man. As he tries to seek out her, he results in a sequence of fascinating locations (an anarchist assembly in a ship, for instance, or the Irish Starvation Memorial), speaking to fascinating individuals (Sylvia’s mates and associates, primarily, but in addition an apparently lonely and chatty Tony Curtis), and having fascinating ideas, a lot of that are involved with factoids he clearly realized whereas doing his job (Audrey Munson, the “American Venus”; the transition to new avenue indicators in New York).
The Truth Checker is an unreliable narrator not solely as a result of he’s telling his story from a take away of at the very least seven years (he mentions Lyft within the final chapter, which was based in 2012), but in addition as a result of at any time when he’s not within the workplace, he’s unceremoniously but steadily consuming, usually to the purpose of blackout. This appears to be extra of an issue than he’s admitting, and it’s not the one self-deception he practices.
He needs to be man: he’s at all times nervous he’s going to be perceived as creepy by the ladies he encounters, he questions his assumptions about individuals he sees, and he’s uncomfortable with the sexism he witnesses amongst male mates and acquaintances. However he additionally by no means interjects when aware of such “guy talk” and he downplays how a lot his personal obsession with discovering Sylvia is linked to his fantasy of her, in addition to how her disappearance reminds him of his ex’s personal behavioral patterns.
The Truth Checker is a fascinating determine not for his personal sake — a pal of Sylvia’s, Agnes, tells him at one level that he’s “a blank man” and he or she’s not unsuitable — however for the inconsistencies in his behaviors, and the dramatic irony inherent within the mismatch between his personal narration and what we, in addition to these round him, start to see in him. “I remember that day well,” the Truth Checker tells us on the ebook’s first web page, however by the top of his first encounter with Sylvia, when she palms him a bag of tomatoes, he thinks, “It seemed intimate, almost flirtatious. Or maybe I’m misremembering the whole thing.”
Whereas “The Fact Checker” is uneven, it’s a enjoyable and fast learn, and it does elevate a number of the most related questions du jour: What’s a reality? What’s fact? And who will get to resolve?
Masad, a books and tradition critic, is the writer of the novel “All My Mother’s Lovers” and the forthcoming novel “Beings.”
