Discover beneath extra details about the ACLU’s lawsuit over e-book bans in DODEA colleges from earlier this summer season.
For years, it’s been clear that probably the most very important methods via this period of e-book censorship is the authorized system. The outcomes of the continuing spate of lawsuits are a combined bag. We’ve seen Iowa’s “Don’t Say Gay” invoice, which includes removing of any books from colleges with so-called “sex acts” in them, be blocked and deemed unconstitutional. We’ve seen the Fifth Circuit Courtroom say that library customers don’t have any First Modification grounds to sue libraries for removing of books for any purpose in Louisiana, Mississippi, and Texas. Librarian Brooky Parks efficiently settled a lawsuit in opposition to her former public library employer, the place she was terminated for talking out in opposition to censorship; so, too, did Suzette Baker in Llano County.
Preserving monitor of the variety of lawsuits over library censorship proper now could be an almost not possible activity as a result of there are such a lot of. Amongst them are fits in Tennessee and South Carolina over bans in public faculty libraries and public libraries respectively; a lawsuit over the usage of BookLooks/RatedBooks to pick out faculty library supplies in Minnesota’s St. Francis Space Faculties (a state the place they’ve an anti-book ban legislation, bear in mind); and a lawsuit over Idaho’s invoice that requires public libraries relocate books mother and father complain about or face monetary penalty.
These don’t even contact on upwards of a dozen extra, nor do they cowl the 2 federal lawsuits occurring over the dismantling of the Institute for Museum and Library Companies (you’ll be able to learn a timeline of this ongoing scenario, together with all the courtroom actions on it, over right here).
One other lawsuit underway proper now could be one which has gotten much less consideration than a few of the others, thanks partly to the censorship concern at play going down outdoors of the “typical” public library and faculty surroundings. One of many first e-book ban directives of the present federal administration got here via the Division of Protection Training Exercise colleges, which fall below the directive of the Division of Protection. This creates a extra direct line for federal calls for than your common public faculty or public library–the IMLS, for instance, doesn’t set insurance policies or procedures for public libraries within the nation, as these are decided on the state and native stage and thus, whereas the monetary assist for libraries will be yanked as we’re seeing now, that doesn’t (but) translate to the company’s chief having the ability to demand all books on sure subjects be banned from public colleges. The identical goes with the Division of Training and public colleges. There are much more hurdles to leap via from the highest down than with the Division of Protection’s Training Exercise colleges.
The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) filed a lawsuit in opposition to the administration for its e-book banning calls for on these colleges.
Sam LaFrance, First Modification Communications Strategist for the ACLU, provides background into the present e-book banning directive, which books are being focused, what led the ACLU to pursue litigation, the present standing of the case, and extra.
***
From Kentucky to Japan, one thing is happening in sure public colleges: books are being taken off the shelf, posters of historic figures like Frida Kahlo are being faraway from partitions, and Black Historical past Month celebrations are being cancelled.
It’s all as a result of the Division of Protection is implementing new insurance policies banning books, classroom discussions, occasions, and extracurriculars that relate to race and gender in military-run colleges on bases around the globe.
So the ACLU took them to courtroom.
What’s DoDEA? Why are they banning books?
The U.S. Division of Protection runs public colleges on their navy bases around the globe for kids of active-duty servicemembers and civilian navy personnel. The company that runs these colleges is named the Division of Protection Training Exercise (DoDEA), and it operates similar to another public faculty district — besides that it’s run by the federal authorities and subsequently is below the direct management of the Secretary of Protection and the Commander in Chief, not a neighborhood faculty board. DoDEA serves over 67,000 college students from kindergarten via highschool in 161 colleges throughout 11 international locations, seven states, Guam, and Puerto Rico.
When you in contrast DoDEA to extra conventional faculty districts in the US, it might be among the many most various, and most excessive reaching, within the nation.
However in January 2025, President Donald Trump signed three government orders that influence DoDEA and the way it operates:
Govt Order (EO) 14168 titled “Defending Women From Gender Ideology Extremism and Restoring Biological Truth to the Federal Government”;
EO 14185 titled “Restoring America’s Fighting Force”; and
EO 14190 titled “Ending Radical Indoctrination in K-12 Schooling”
These government orders prohibit, amongst different issues, the usage of federal funds for something that will promote “gender ideology” or “divisive concepts,” the latter of which has lengthy been interpreted to cowl a big selection of subjects associated to race, intercourse, and American historical past. EO 14185 specific instructs the navy to cease “promoting, advancing or otherwise inculcating” a number of “un-American, divisive, discriminatory, radical, extremist, and irrational theories” — all of which implicate books and curricula that relate to race and gender, as we have now seen in public colleges across the nation since 2021.
In President Trump’s phrases, these ideas add as much as “wokeness”:
[W]e are getting wokeness out of our colleges and out of our navy and it’s already out and it’s out of our society, we don’t need it. Wokeness is bother, wokeness is unhealthy, it’s gone. It’s gone. And we really feel so a lot better for it, don’t we? Don’t we really feel higher?
What precisely are they doing?
Utilizing key phrase searches, supplies had been recognized for potential noncompliance with the chief orders prohibiting so-called “gender ideology” and “divisive concepts.” That evaluate is ongoing at DoDEA HQ – and their resolution may influence college students in colleges from Kentucky to Japan. In DoDEA’s personal phrases, all of this occurred in response to President Trump’s government orders and steering from Secretary of Protection Pete Hegseth. The influence is already being felt.
A coaching at a college in Germany, librarians had been instructed to scan books for potential references to gender id; one e-book, Each Sides Now by Peyton Thomas, was flagged as in violation as a result of it “refers to transgender.”
A number of books and assets had been faraway from the curriculum, together with chapters of two AP Psychology books that mentioned human sexuality and a traditionally correct, grade-appropriate biography of Robert Cashier, a civil struggle veteran who was born feminine however enlisted and fought valiantly as a person within the Union Military.
This censorship prolonged into intercourse training, too. A number of chapters had been banned from DoDEA intercourse ed textbooks, together with:
“Communicable Diseases: Sexually Transmitted Diseases”;
“Unwanted Sexual Activity: Sexual Harassment”;
“Human Reproductive System, Menstrual Cycle, and Fetal Development”;
“Abuse and Neglect”; and
“Adolescence and Puberty”
The company left no stone unturned. Even faculty yearbooks had been implicated: no “visual depictions, written content, or editorial choices” that will point out assist for “social transition” was allowed.
All of this violates the First Modification.
College students in DoDEA colleges, similar to different college students in American public colleges, have a proper to obtain details about the world round them. They’ve a proper to learn books about their very own experiences or the experiences of individuals which might be totally different from them, they usually have a proper to have their training formed not by animus or politics however by pedagogical experience, curiosity, and academic rigor.
What books had been banned?
In accordance to a brand new submitting from DoDEA, 555 books and 41 curricular supplies have been banned on bases around the globe whereas they endure evaluate. DoDEA doesn’t wish to say what these books are, however we’ve compiled a listing of some titles that seem like included, and the courtroom ordered a full record by mid-June.
Freckleface Strawberry by Julianne Moore
To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee
Julián Is a Mermaid by Jessica Love
4 entries within the Heartstopper collection by Alice Oseman
I Kissed Shara Wheeler by Casey McQuiston
The Coloration Purple by Alice Walker
The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration within the Age of Colorblindness by Michelle Alexander
The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini
The Nickel Boys by Colson Whitehead (and The Dozier Faculty for Boys: Forensics, Survivors, and a Painful Previous by Elizabeth A. Murray, in regards to the faculty on which this novel was primarily based).
Regardless of pleas from mother and father, college students, and advocates, DoDEA has so far refused to verify which 555 books are formally on the chopping block systemwide. However primarily based on what we all know, as with different faculty districts, the overwhelming majority of books allegedly banned inside DoDEA seem like by or about girls, LGBTQ folks, and other people of coloration.
What’s being finished about it?
The American Civil Liberties Union, together with the ACLU of Kentucky and the ACLU of Virginia, filed swimsuit in opposition to DoDEA in March on behalf of six households with kids in DoDEA colleges. These households have kids starting from kindergarten to eleventh grade in colleges around the globe.
The swimsuit argues that these removals violate the First Modification. As described within the preliminary criticism, the removals and bans will not be primarily based on “rational, age-appropriate, evidence-based concerns” however on politics and the President’s “anti-wokeness” agenda. This limits college students’ capability to suppose critically, find out about themselves and their neighbors, and within the case of intercourse ed supplies, even preserve themselves secure from hurt.
On Tuesday, June 3, 2025, the ACLU argued within the Jap District of Virginia that the courtroom ought to grant a direct preliminary injunction – restoring curriculum, placing books again on the shelf, and stopping DoDEA from persevering with to implement the chief orders that brought about all of this. The courtroom may concern a call at any time and on the listening to, the courtroom ordered DoDEA to share extra details about the eliminated books inside seven days.However the battle received’t simply be received within the courtroom – scholar organizers in DoDEA colleges have been main walkouts in protest of those new insurance policies, usually risking disciplinary motion, since January. In South Korea, 40 college students participated in a single such walkout, which included a flag folding ceremony and a scholar dressed because the Statue of Liberty. And navy mother and father, like those bringing the lawsuit, have spoken out about how incongruous this spate of censorship is with their jobs: “We make sacrifices as a military family so that my husband can defend the Constitution and the rights and freedoms of all Americans,” mentioned one such mother or father. “If our own rights and the rights of our children are at risk, we have a responsibility to speak out.”
